My Article on tax reform in the Financial Times

« Mouseketeer Patriotism | Main | The Democratic Debate »

09/04/2003

My Article on tax reform in the Financial Times

Since linking to the FT requires a subscription, here's the full text. This is an argument that I've been making to some of the presidential campaigns.

September 4, 2003, Thursday USA Edition 2

SECTION: COMMENT; Pg. 13

LENGTH: 932 words

HEADLINE: A Bush tax plan for the Democrats: MARK SCHMITT:

BYLINE: By MARK SCHMITT

BODY:
It is worth recalling just how George W. Bush distinguished himself on the issue of taxes in the 2000 presidential campaign. It was not by promising tax cuts: both Mr Bush and Al Gore, then vice-president, pledged to use much of the projected budget surplus to reduce taxes. Nor did Mr Bush emphasise that his cuts would be bigger, or that he would cut taxes "every single year", as his advisers now suggest.

Instead, Mr Bush sold voters a simple and wise principle: unlike Mr Gore, who put forward a tortured programme of incentives to encourage certain activities and benefit certain categories of taxpayers, Mr Bush promised that his policies would not "pick and choose" among taxpayers based upon their source of income or expenses but would benefit everyone and "simplify the code . . . particularly for those at the bottom end of the income ladder".

As Democratic presidential candidates face up to the fact that they cannot restore fiscal sanity or improve healthcare without reclaiming some or all of the Dollars 3,000bn in revenues lost in the three Bush tax cuts, they should not forget this decisive exchange, which was repeated in all three of the 2000 presidential debates. For it contains two lessons in how they should talk about taxes and economics.

First, there is the fact that it is a broken promise. The tax code now does more "picking and choosing" than at any time since the 1970s. While a decade ago there were just three income tax rates, there are now in effect dozens of rates, depending on what year it is and whether your income comes from work, dividends or capital gains. Dividend income alone will be taxed at 10 different rates. The expansion of benefits for the working poor is good, but involves at least four different credits with different requirements, forcing a single parent earning Dollars 20,000 to fill in a tax return as complicated as a millionaire's.

Such a system rewards dishonesty and accounting gimmicks over hard work and real investment. When some investment income is still taxed at both the corporate and the individual level, while other profits are never taxed at all, countless incentives are created to alter business plans to shift income into tax-favoured categories. These transactions absorb money that could otherwise be used to generate growth.

There may be a larger vision here, albeit an unspoken one. Perhaps it is the ideology that investment income should not be taxed at all. Perhaps it is a plan to sow such chaos that a flat tax or consumption tax becomes inevitable. But in any case, the administration has asked to be judged by results - and the results so far are a mess.

Stanley Greenberg, the Democratic pollster, has argued that the most appealing tax changes for voters are reforms such as closing the loophole that allows companies to incorporate tax-free in Bermuda. This is where the second lesson of the Bush-Gore exchanges comes in: such changes are policy specifics, not principles.

Imagine instead that Democrats learnt from Mr Bush and, instead of battling about the details of revenue sources, loopholes and the like, simply put forward a set of principles that should guide the next president and Congress. These might comprise the following. People in the same situation should pay the same tax, whether their income comes from work or investments. Tax rates should be predictable, so people can plan for the future. Total revenues, over the long term, should be based on the cost of the services that voters decide they want from government, so tax cuts, in a time of deficits, cannot be separated from either cuts in services or future tax increases. Middle-class people should not need accountants to do their taxes; and the tax code should encourage low-income working families and reward work, but without unnecessary complexity.

Voters should have a chance to choose between these principles, which are similar to Mr Bush's 2000 promise, and the reality of the current tax code. A Democratic presidential candidate might propose a commission to revamp the tax code from scratch, or some specifics, such as a single tax credit for working families that brings together the four existing, complex credits.

Once before, US politicians confronted a tax code that had gone wildly awry (the top rate was supposedly 70 per cent but with so many exceptions that many wealthy individuals and companies paid nothing) and revamped the code around sound principles: low rates that applied to everyone, incentives for low-income families and simplicity. It was a bipartisan breakthrough, ultimately signed into law in 1986 by President Ronald Reagan. But it met opposition - from a few liberals who liked the higher rates, even if they were entirely symbolic; from lobby groups; and, above all, from powerful Texans, whose oil and gas industries benefited the most from tax shelters.

The lobbyists and the Texans are today even more powerful than in the 1980s. They would love the debate in 2004 to focus exclusively on whether to repeal the tax cuts. Instead, the choice should be between a tax code that distorts the economy and picks winners, and one based on sound principles of fairness and economic neutrality. Such a choice would not only give Democrats an opportunity to spotlight Mr Bush's broken promise but also offer a chance to put America's economy on a sounder footing for the future.

The writer is director of policy and research for the Open Society Institute's US programmes, and was a senior advisor to former Senator Bill Bradley's 2000 presidential campaign

Posted by Mark Schmitt on 09/04/2003 at 06:25 PM in Decembrist archives | Permalink

Comments

You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

(ASIAN ELECTRONICS COMPANY LTD. )

OFFICE ADDRESS: 10, LIVERPOOL STREET APAPA
LAGOS NIGERIA.

BOBBY BUMPER
SALES AND MARKETING DEPARTMENT MANAGER
E-mail: [email protected]
TELL: +234-8038259271

WE ARE IN PARTNERSHIP WITH SOUTH KOREA COMPANY,UK,MALAYSIA,FINLAND, HUNGARY, CANADA AND USA.

WE ARE SELLING LOTS OF MOBILE PHONES AND LAPTOPS FOR VERY CHEAP PRICE AND THESE PHONES ARE THE LATEST PHONES ALSO THEY SELLS A LOT IN MARKET SO THEY ARE AS FOLLOW'''''''''''''

SONY VAIO A217S-- 100GB-- 512MB RAM-- XP HOME-------------$320
SONY VAIO B1VP-- 40GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP PRO--------------$290
SONY VAIO T370P/L-- 60GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP----------------$320
SONY VAIO A215Z 60GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP------------------$400
SONY VAIO A397XP-- 80GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP----------------$450
SONY VAIO B100B08 60GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP---------------$280
SONY VAIO B100B08 60GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP---------------$300
SONY VAIO FS295VP 80GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP---------------$250
SONY VAIO FS215Z 100GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP---------------$350
SONY VAIO A417M 80GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP-----------------$300
SONY VAIO B1VP-- 40GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP PRO-------------$200
SONY VAIO T370P/L-- 60GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP PRO----------$360
SONY VAIO LAPTOP-- VGN-A117S----------------------------------$420
SONY VAIO LAPTOP-- VGN-S1XP------------------------------------$400
ALPHASMART DANA PALM POWERED LAPTOP------------------------$260
APPLE G4 POWERBOOK 1.5GHZ SUPERDRIVE WITH 15 INCH DISPLAY--$350
APPLE G5 POWERMAC 2.0GHZ DESKTOP COMPUTER-------------$520
APPLE G4 POWERBOOK 1.5GHZ SUPERDRIVE WITH 17 INCH DISPLAY--$410
APPLE G5 POWERMAC 2.5GHZ DESKTOP COMPUTER---------$100
TOSHIBA SATELLITE LAPTOP-- P20-102--------------------------$260
APPLE 5GHZ SUPERDRIVE DESKTOP COMPUTER WITH 20 INCH MONITOR-$310
ALPHASMART DANA PALM POWERED LAPTOP PACK WIFI VERSION-$280
OQO MODEL 01 ULTRA PERSONAL COMPUTER (XP PRO)--------------$270
TOSHIBA SATELLITE PRO A60 40GB-- C2.8GHZ-- 15INCH-- DVD/CDR$320
FLYBOOK NOTEBOOK - WI-FI-- GPRS-- BLUETOOTH-- 1GHZ (BLACK)----$270
FUJITSU SIEMENS LIFEBOOK P7010 60GB-- P4 1.1GHZ-- 10.6INCH-- DVD/CDRW
$600
ASUS A4744K-LH AMD64 POWER WORKSTATION LAPTOP--------$360
FLYBOOK NOTEBOOK - WI-FI-- GPRS-- BLUETOOTH-- 1GHZ (RED)------$380
FLYBOOK NOTEBOOK - WI-FI-- GPRS-- BLUETOOTH-- 1GHZ (BLUE)-----$290
ALPHASMART DANA PALM POWERED LAPTOP------------------------$300
FLYBOOK NOTEBOOK - WI-FI-- GPRS-- BLUETOOTH-- 1GHZ (YELLOW)--$230
TOSHIBA TECRA M2 40GB-- PM 1.5GHZ-- 14INCH-- WIFI-- DVD-CDRW----$310
FLYBOOK NOTEBOOK - WI-FI-- GPRS-- BLUETOOTH-- 1GHZ (SILVER)---$270
TOSHIBA PORTEGE R100 40GB-- 512MB-- XP PRO------------------$450
TOSHIBA SATELLITE LAPTOP-- M30-742-------------------------------$550
APPLE G5 POWERMAC 1.8GHZ DESKTOP COMPUTER--------------$500
HP PAVILION LAPTOP-- ZD7145EA-----------------------------------$500
HP PAVILION LAPTOP-- ZD7255EA-----------------------------------$500
APPLE CINEMA HD 23-INCH TFT LCD MONITOR---------------------$500
SONY VAIO LAPTOP-- VGN PCGK21 5Z----------------------------$500
SAMSUNG LAPTOP-- X30 LWC 1500--------------------------------$500
G4 POWERBOOK 1.33GHZ SUPERDRIVE WITH 12 INCH DISPLAY-$600
SONY VAIO PCVW2 DESKTOP-------------------------------------$450
HP PAVILION LAPTOP-- ZX5151EA PHOTOSMART-------------------$400
TOSHIBA SATELLITE LAPTOP-- M30-832----------------------------$400
HP PAVILION LAPTOP-- ZT3215EA----------------------------------$550
SAMSUNG LAPTOP-- M40 HWM 745--------------------------------$500

MOBILE PHONES.

VIEW OUR PRICE LIST BELOW -- ALL BRAND NEW UNITS:

Cellphones...
Nokia N93====250 USD
Nokia N92====230 USD,
Nokia N90====220 USD,
Nokia N80====200 USD
Nokia 8800====180 USD,
Nokia N70====170 USD,
Nokia 6680====140 USD,
Nokia N71====175 USD
Nextel 1930====130USD,
Nextel 1860=====112USD,
Nextel 1870====130 USD
Pamtero 600====140 USD,
Pamtero 650====150 USD,
Treo 650====130 USD
Treo 700====180 USD
Sony Ericsson P800-- US$155
Sony Ericsson P900-- US$205
Sony Ericsson P910i-- US$210
Sony Ericsson T20e-- US$35
Sony Ericsson T20s-- US$39
Sony Ericsson T28s-- US$39
Sony Ericsson T28 World-- US$45
Sony Ericsson T29s-- US$49
Sony Ericsson T100-- US$30
Sony Ericsson T105-- US$35
Sony Ericsson T200-- US$45
Sony Ericsson T230-- US$55
Sony Ericsson T300-- US$55
Sony Ericsson T310-- US$50
Sony Ericsson T600-- US$69
Sony Ericsson T610-- US$130
Sony Ericsson T630-- US$135
Sony Ericsson T68i-- US$105
Sony Ericsson T68m-- US$110
Sony Ericsson Z200-- US$100
Sony Ericsson Z600-- US$170
Sony CMD-J5-- US$30
Sony CMD-Z7-- US$35
Sony CMD-J7-- US$40
Sony CMD-J6-- US$40
Sony CMD-Z5-- US$90
Sony CMD-MZ5-- US$155
Sony Ericsson R520m-- US$100
Sony Ericsson R380 World-- US$90
Sony Ericsson R380s-- US$105
Sony Ericsson R600-- US$35
Sony Ericsson S700-- US$175
Sony Ericsson K500i-- US$180
Sony Ericsson K700i-- US$189
Motorola A008-- US$50
Motorola A388-- US$70
Motorola A388c-- US$120
Motorola A820-- US$65
Motorola C330-- US$20
Motorola C331-- US$25
Motorola C332-- US$30
Motorola C333-- US$35
Motorola C350-- US$69
Motorola E360-- US$60
Motorola E365-- US$110
Motorola E380-- US$95
Motorola E398-- US$125
Motorola MPX200-- US$180
Motorola Accompli 008-- US$49
Motorola Timeport 280-- US$80
Motorola T190T-- US$25
Motorola Talkabout 191-- US$25
Motorola T720-- US$65
Motorola T720i-- US$85
Motorola V3Razor-- US$145
Motorola V66-- US$60
Motorola V60-- US$70
Motorola V60i-- US$75

BOBBY BUMPER
SALES AND MARKETING DEPARTMENT MANAGER
E-mail: [email protected]
TELL: +234-8038259271

Posted by: BOBBY BUMPER | 10/23/2006 at 11:30 AM

he Management of ELITE ELECTRONICS are launching out there product out to general public, We are given Buy 2 Get 1 Apple Ipod 20gb. All our product are brand new,

Complete accessories(Well packed and sealed in original company box)
Unlocked / sim free.
Brand new (original manufacturer) box - no copies
All phones have english language asdefault
All material (software, manual) - car chargers - home chargers - usb data cables -holsters/belt clips - wireless headsets(bluetooth) - leather and non-leather carrying cases - batteries. if you are interested, forward your questions and enquires to us via email with your order and shipping details. we give 1 year warranty for every product sold out to our costumers, our product are company class 1 tested and approved by global standard organization of wireless industries, Brand new merchandise with complete accessories, extra charger and battery.serious buyers should. Contact us on: E-mail:[email protected] Nokia Brand new Nokia n93 $230usd Brand new Nokia n92 $190usd Brand new Nokia n91 $180usd Brand new Nokia n90 $150usd Brand new Nokia n72 $150usd Brand new Nokia n73 $160usd Brand new Nokia n83 $170usd Brand new Nokia n80 $165usd Brand new Nokia e73 $165usd Brand new Nokia n70 $160usd Brand new Nokia E61 $150usd Brand new Nokia 7200 $195usd Brand new Nokia 9300 $190usd Brand new Nokia 7250i $175usd Brand new Nokia 8800 $220usd Brand new Nokia 9210i communicator $160usd Brand new Nokia 9500 communicator $170usd Brand new Nokia 9300 communicator..$200usd Samsungs Brand new Samsung Q1 $200 Brand new Samsung SGH-e910 $180usd Brand new Samsung p850 $200usd Brand new Samsung d500 $140usd Brand new Samsung e600 $180usd Brand new Samsung e800 $160usd Brand new Samsung sgh-d410 $270usd Brand new Samsung sgh-e700 $150usd Brand new Samsung sgh-e715 $170usd Brand new Samsung sgh-p100 $130usd Brand new Samsung sgh-p400 $100usd Brand new Samsung SGH-Z510 $150usd Brand new Samsung SGH-p300 $180usd Brand new Samsung SGH-i300 $185usd Brand new Samsung sgh-p408 $240usd Brand new Samsung sgh-p730 $150usd Brand new Samsung sgh-s300m $100usd Brand new Samsung x450 $100usd Brand new Samsung SCH-i730 $130usd Motorola Brand new Motorola Q1 $200 Brand new Motorola pebl u6 $150usd Brand new Motorola a1200 $200usd Brand new Motorola a1010 $180usd Brand new Motorola a1000 $170usd Brand new Motorola a388c $170usd Brand new Motorola a760 $166usd Brand new Motorola a768 $170usd Brand new Motorola a768i $160usd Brand new Motorola a780 $170usd Brand new Motorola i860 $135usd Brand new Motorola Mpx 300 $150usd Brand new Motorola Mpx 220 $140usd Brand new Motorola V6 $150usd Brand new Motorola L7 $165usd Brand new Motorola e680 $200usd Brand new Motorola razor v3 $90usd Brand new Motorola v220 $170usd Brand new Motorola v80 with Bluetooth $260usd Brand new Motorola v872 $200usd Sony ericsson Brand new Sony Ericsson k790A $230usd Brand new Sony Ericsson p990 $200usd Brand new Sony Ericsson w900 $180usd Brand new Sony Ericsson Z525a $200usd Brand new Sony Ericsson W710i $190usd Brand new Sony Ericsson Z710i $200usd Brand new Sony Ericsson W300i $180usd Brand new Sony Ericsson K310 $180usd Brand new Sony Ericsson M600 $200usd Brand new Sony Ericsson j100 $240usd Brand new Sony ericsson k500i $130usd Brand new Sony Ericsson p800 $140usd Brand new Sony Ericsson p900 $150usd Brand new Sony Ericsson p910 $180usd Brand new Sony Ericsson z1010 $160usd Brand new Sony Ericsson z600 $130usd Brand new Sony Ericsson s700i $150usd Brand new Sony Ericsson s750i $180usd Brand new Sony Ericsson W800i $180usd Sidekick Brand new Sidekick 3 $150usd Brand new Sidekick 2 $120usd Brand new Pink couture sidekick 2 $155usd Brand new Mr. Cartoon sidekick $150usd E-ten Brand new ETEN G500......$200usd Brand new Eten M500......$180usd Brand new ETEN M600......$200usd Nextel Brand new NEXTEL I930 ...$130USD Brand new NEXTEL I870....$120USD Brand new NEXTEL I860....$100USD Treo Brand new The Treo 700w...$190 Brand new The Treo 650....$140 Brand new The Treo 700p...$190 Imate Brand new I-mate JAM 850...$140 Brand new I-MATE K-JAM ...$270 Brand new i-MATE JASJAR.....$200 Blackberry Brand new BlackBerry 8700r....$200 Brand new Blackberry 8700c....$200 Brand new Blackberry 8700g....$210 Apple Ipod Brand new Apple iPod nano 4GB....$131.50us Brand new Apple iPod nano 2GB....$112.00us Brand new Apple 30 GB Video iPod....$140.50us Brand new Apple 60 GB Video iPod....$155.00us Brand new Apple 20 GB iPod : $126.00USD Brand new Apple 4 GB iPod Mini....$105.00USD Brand new Apple 6 GB iPod Mini...$114.00USD Brand new Apple 40 GB iPod photo....$110.00USD Brand new Apple 60 GB iPod photo....$130.00USD Brand new Apple 30 GB iPod Photo....$116.00 Brand new Apple 512 MB iPod Shuffle MP3 Player....$94.00 Brand new Video Game Brand new Xbox 360 ...$200 Brand new Psp (play station)..$145

My name is collins and am from california,sandiego,am 37 years of age.am looking for cool and beautiful young lady for a lasting relationship.

Posted by: collins | 10/28/2006 at 09:22 PM

This is a great article. I am new to your blog and i like what I see. I look forward to your future work.

Posted by: Sean | 11/13/2006 at 05:04 AM

The Las Vegas community offers cultural activities, lots of recreational chances, a particular variety of restaurants, and several shopping venues. No other market in the US saw a particular better increase. How Much Should Your Income Be?: What income is demanded to qualify for a particular mortgage? The choices are better than ever within house styles, life styles, and costs! I'm a particular special HENDERSON resident having been born within addition to raised in Hungary. North Las Vegas real estate consists of single-household houses and townhouses and condominiums.

Posted by: Wally Smith | 12/08/2006 at 12:02 PM